Saturday, October 22, 2016

Using the database of the National Gallery of Art to estimate the frequecy of oil as a medium in Italian art before the High Renaissance.

  •    The National Gallery Of Art , Washington, DC. has 145 Italian paintings made between 1400 and 1500.
  •    None were made in Rome.
  •    Omitting the 15 that were made between 1495 and 1500,  leaves 130 made before the High Renaissance.  
  •    Only 28 paintings of the 130 paintings made before the 1595 used oil. It was in combination with tempera (14 Paintings) and oil alone (14 paintings).
  •    15 paintings were made from 1495 -1500. 14 were oil and 1 was tempera. The one tempera piece was done in 1495.
  •    Considering that the National Galley probably has a representative collection and that 130 paintings is an adequate sampling size, 1495 can be used as a watershed year when oil replaced tempra in Italian Renaissance art.
Bellini, Giovanni, Venetian, c. 1430/1435 - 1516
Madonna and Child in a Landscape 
c. 1480/1485 
oil on panel 

Lippi, Filippino,  Florentine, 1457 - 1504
The Adoration of the Child 
c. 1475/1480 
oil on poplar panel

Thursday, July 14, 2016

Insights and Symbolism in Max Beckmann’s The Dream

The Dream. Max Beckmann, 1921
In the room of Max Beckman paintings at the Saint Louis Art Museum, rarely does anyone stop at The Dream. It’s a walk by. The work is cryptic and not easily accessible without some familiarity of Beckmann and the dismal state of affairs of post war Weimar Germany. Picasso’s Guernica has more symbolism but with the plethora of web sites that decode Guernica, crowds gather in front of the massive image and in a polyglot of recitations, spout “their” interpretations.

The 5 people in The Dream are tightly packed into small room in an attic, the room of a building with the lowest rent and inhabited by the least socially acceptable. The three men are invalids. One has amputations of both legs, another of both hands, and the third man is blind. Men with amputations were a common sight in German cities after the war. During WWI the lethal advances in armament technology outstripped medical advances. Without amputations, mud contaminated shrapnel wounds with exposed bone would become infected with sepsis or gangrene. The prevailing use of occlusive bandages was part of the problem. Blindness often developed because of the use of chlorine and phosgene gasses as weapons. A street organ is hanging from his neck and he is wearing a sign to remind people to be thankful for the light in their eyes and not to forget the poor blind man. Most of the blind veterans were reduced to begging or selling pencils. The girl who is sitting on a trunk with labels for Lehrter, a Berlin railroad station, is most likely a newly arrived prostitute from a village. Her long straight hair is not bobbed in the fashionable flapper style or bubikopf that was seen in the cities. When Beckmann was working on The Dream, inflation was almost triple digits. The economic ruin of many middle class families meant that unskilled women employed as domestics were suddenly unemployed. The large number of prostitutes continued to increase as single women and widows moved to Berlin. Her left forearm and hand are in a position as if she were requesting money. She is the only person in the room with her eyes open. She stares at the bizarre events and her Kaspar doll claps his hands in approval. The yellow strands dripping out of the sleeping woman’s dress are the purulent discharge of a venereal disease. Beckmann wasn’t the only artist during the New Objectivity to overtly portray venereal disease. Two Victims of Capitalism (1923) by Otto Dix shows a prostitute with a syphilitic lesion on her face that looks like a bullet hole and a veteran with a large gaping shrapnel wound on his cheek that is shaped like a vagina.

The room is out of kilter because of the floor, which is unusual in paintings or set designs. The effect is usually because the ceiling or walls are not plumb. The floor is like one large stretcher that was used to transport the wounded from the battlefield to the crowded medical facilities where they were not likely to leave intact. The slanted picture frame behind the blind man is a dormer window that goes nowhere. The characters are trapped in this crowded space. The characters on the sloping floor and ladder unify this atypically tall and narrow painting vertically.

Beckmann was fascinated by Northern Gothic paintings, with their foregrounds packed with people with angular forms and no rules of perspective. During his post battlefield period of depression complicated with agitation and nightmares he painted several paintings of Christ’s suffering.
Descent from the Cross. Max Beckmann, 1917
Descent from the Cross (1917) has jagged, angular observers and an emaciated Christ with elongated arms. A large ladder towers over a small cross.

Self Portrait with a Red Scarf (1917)
Beckmann served from 1914 to 1915 as a medical orderly. He was released from service because of shell shock or what today would be called Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Crowded Claustrophobic works appeared in his work after he was released from the army. The colors are thin and light. Skin tones look like cadavers. His Self Portrait with a Red Scarf (1917) reveals himself with an ashen emaciated face, sunken eyes and prominent facial bones.

Self- portrait with Champagne Glass (1919) 
Self- portrait with Champagne Glass was done after series of political assassinations in January 1919 and a few months after he was in Berlin during street battles of the March Rebellion of 1919. He still has the same appearance but now he is able to hold the champagne glass upright while everything else in the painting is distorted. Alcohol could provide the escape and comfort needed in a violent distorted city.

Nailing of Christ to the Cross, Master of the 
Karlsruhe Passion c. 1450.
The Dream has been compared to Nailing of Christ to the Cross (c. 1450) by Master of the Karlsruhe Passion. Art historian and former curator at the Museum of Modern Art, Peter Selz has noted that the boy kneeling on the cross and staring at the viewer is in the same location as the young girl in The Dream. The sleeping maid is in the same position as the soldier tying the rope on the cross. The man driving the nail into Jesus’ hand is in a similar location as the man with a bandage on his amputated hand. The fish partially lying on the ladder has been substituted for Christ lying on the cross. The ladder, a symbol for the ascension, a connection between heaven and earth, goes nowhere in this painting.

Beckmann’s use of somnambulists may be related to the German Expressionist film The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari that was released in early 1920 and featured an insane hypnotist who commands a somnambulist to commit murders. The men in The Dream, two of them now wearing circus costumes, blindly marched off to war during the fervor of the August Madness, under the control of the folly of their Government.

The suffering of the German people after WWI doesn’t arouse the sympathy that victims of Nazi atrocities do. Future generations exposed to revisionist history are the ones who will realize that without a vindictive Versailles Treaty and the impossible reparations payments imposed on Germany, there might not have been a Guernica.

The signage next to the Beckmann paintings in Saint Louis is paltry and provides a pittance of information that doesn’t help much to decode his enigmatic works. The room will continue to be a walk by for most visitors. Wake Up Saint Louis and Show Me MOre information.

Thursday, June 23, 2016

A Closer Look at Mary Cassatt's The Boating Party – some Design Elements and Principles

A digital image of her painting was traced in Photoshop for this project in an Art Appreciation class.

Parallel lines predominate in this painting. There are the lines of the seats in the boat, the shoreline and the horizon line beyond the low hills of green. Repetitions of parallel horizontal lines in the water that let us know that the water is not still. The line of the man's arm joins the lines of the oar forming an angle that points to the baby. The curved white lines of the gunwale of the boat unite the three people in the boat. The curved lines of the sail and the rigging point to the woman.  The man's trouser forms another line with the yellow seat. The woman’s dress has a crisscrossing pattern of three parallel red lines and the baby’s dress a pattern of red stripes.


Cool colors predominate with the dark blue of the man's clothing, the blue of the water, and the yellow–green of the inside of the boat. The sail, mother’s hat, shirt, and baby’s hat are a similar unsaturated, pastel like light green. The low hills are a more saturated green. It’s a very limited palette. The only warm colors are localized – the muted red pattern in her dress, the baby’s dress, and the flesh tones. There are some small red tiled roofs in the background. It is a sunny day and there is almost no reduction in value or saturation to the background.

The horizon line is extremely high in the painting. The position of the artist drawing the image or a camera taking such a photograph would have to be immediately behind the man and higher than his head because he occupies such a large space and his head is lower than the shore line. Taking an actual measurement from the man’s contact with the seat to his head is almost twice that of the woman. Although she is farther away from the camera or artist, the woman's head (not the hat) is at the shoreline while the man’s head is below the shoreline. The bow of the boat is not elevated out of the water enough to cause this discrepancy. Think when you go to the movies it's the person in the row in front of you who is blocking the screen and not a smaller person two rows in front of you. The woman is being drawn from a lower angle to obtain this effect.

The picture is highly asymmetrical with the man occupying a large portion of the foreground on the right. Balance is achieved by placing the sail on the far left. By not seeing the entire sail, we might wonder how far to the left it continues. The woman and her daughter are to the left of the man. There is a complex line of sight in the center of the painting. We only see a small portion of the man’s left eye and we might infer that he is looking at the baby. Societal proprieties and class structure of the Belle Époque would not have the boatman and this fashionably dressed mother looking at each other. For the mother to have hired the boatman was pushing the limits. The mother's shoulder line is oblique with her left shoulder as far as possible away from the man. The mother is looking below the man's eyes. The baby is looking at him. Trying to interpret the complex body language takes our attention to the center of the painting.  Also using the reddish colors for the pattern in the dress and the child's clothing tends to offset the cool colors on the right side.

The color of the back of the man's jacket and seat of his pants shows minimal variation in color. Most of his backside is flat like a drawing in a comic book. There are variations in the color of his waistband with several parallel lines. These repeated lines and color value variations of the waistband give a sense of texture to the fabric. The dark oblique line near the upper edge of the waistband reveals that there is a fold in the material. The repeating red lines in the dress give depth and form to the dress. The red line pattern is in the shape of an arch in the skirt to show that the fabric is draping over her thighs. The three lined pattern runs obliquely from the knees to the bottom of the skirt to show that the fabric is draped over her legs. The variations used in painting the dress pattern give the appearance of volume to the dress. 

The curved lines of the sail show the force of the wind billowing the sail.  In addition to the parallel broken lines in the water, variations in color value of the water let us know that the water is not flat or still. The man is leaning forward and bracing his foot against the seat. He is ready to make another stroke with the oar.


There is a lot going on in this painting and we only have discussed three elements of design – line, color, and motion, and two design principles – balance and scale.



Effect of Color to Balance Asymmetry



Mary Cassatt used a small amount of red color in the baby’s dress and in the pattern of the woman’s dress to contribute to achieving balance in the painting The Boating Party. 


If she had painted their clothing a similar color to the man’s clothes, our attention would tend to stay on the right side of the painting instead of on the baby. The red color adds, another principle of design to this work – VARIETY.



Effect of Shape to Balance Asymmetry


A large shape has a big effect to achieve balance. In The Boating Party the sail on the left is what is having the greatest effect on balancing the painting.


Here is how the painting would appear without the sail. The oar going off frame does provide some balance, but not as much as the sail and rigging pointing at he woman.



    


Friday, June 17, 2016

Getting to Know Alfred and Georgia Through Film – Documentary vs Narrative

Two films about Alfred Stieglitz and Georgia O'Keefe provide both historical facts and insights about this enigmatic union. They also are a wonderful way to compare the weaknesses and strengths that narrative and documentary films have about the same subject. 


The Georgia O’Keeffe film, directed by Bob Balaban, focuses on several intimate moments in the lives of O’Keeffe and Stieglitz to reveal the abusive, manipulative and narcissistic behavior of Stieglitz. It was a made for television film that first aired in 2009. However, 89 minutes is not enough time to cover the complexities of her life and the tumultuous relationship with Stieglitz. 

Opening credits over images of her paintings are followed by a breathtaking view of  mountains outside her studio in Abiquiu, New Mexico. There is a first person narration of an older O'Keefe as the camera tracks back into her actual studio, not a set, to reveal that she is painting the scene. Cinema aficionados would not include this shot on their list of best tracking shots, but to O'Keeffe devotees, it borders on the sublime. 

There is a shift to New York, 1916, with a young O’Keeffe going into Stieglitz’s gallery, telling him that she is Georgia O’Keeffe and demanding that he take  down her paintings that he is displaying without her permission. He gives her a speech on how he has put her work next to Picasso and Matisse and she gives in. O’Keeffe feels she is in control when she asserts herself to have Alfred move the bed under the skylight before she moves into the apartment that he uses for a darkroom. She wants to be able to see the stars move around his head when he decides to visit her. She slaps his hands when he starts to undress her blouse while he is photographing her, so she can do it herself. O’Keeffe sees the nude photographs of herself that Alfred has displayed without her permission for a gallery opening of her paintings. She accepts his explanation of why she should embrace his benevolent gesture of promoting her work. His behavior becomes cruel when he openly has an affair with Dorothy Norman the rich benefactor of his gallery. At the Stieglitz family house in Lake George, Georgia has to watch them flirt and openly talk about having sex.  The scene when Georgia sees him photographing and sensually posing Dorothy is very difficult to watch.

He has an intense tirade because she took a commission at Radio City Music Hall without asking him, because he could have negotiated a higher fee. She falls into a deep depression. He brings the most pitifully small bunch of flowers when visits her in the hospital. Lying on the bed in a catatonic state and not able to speak, he immediately starts in about how he has a whole new show planned to showcase her paintings.

Alfred Stieglitz: The Eloquent Eye, an American Masters Series documentary released in 2001, is a treasure trove of information but you don't watch it for watch it for entertainment. 

Stieglitz’s description in the documentary, in voice over, about how he photographed The Steerage in 1907 reveals an inconsistency in his understanding of why the photograph is considered one of the greatest images in the history of photography. He describes the shapes and angles of the upper level, stairway, booms and masts making triangles, and how he saw shapes related to each other. However, he didn’t learn about these shapes and angles until much later. Max Weber claims he saw the photo in 1910 while he was looking at photos in Stieglitz’s studio. He claims to be the first to tell Stieglitz why the picture was so good. After the photo was first published in Camera Work in 1911, he definitely knew about the aesthetic merits of the photograph. 

On board the SS Kaiser Wilhelm II during a European Grand Tour with his rich wife, daughter and governess, he saw the lower steerage deck scene when he was taking a promenade on the First Class deck. He didn’t have his camera with him and had to run back to his stateroom. He thought the picture depended on the man with the straw hat on the upper deck and the man with the crossed suspenders on the lower deck. He was afraid that the man with the straw hat would move. “If he had the picture wouldn’t exist.” Stieglitz has merged his 1907 memory of the event with his later memories of what people were saying about the picture. Yes, he saw something that would make a good photograph but the man with the straw hat is a very minor component of the image. 



Photogravure of The Steerage, that was taken in 1907, but not published until 1911.   















I have placed colored lines over the main lines and objects in the photograph. 














The  photograph layer has been removed. 















Suprematism  by Kazimir Malevich. 1915. 


Stieglitz's later analysis and writings about The Steerage were influenced  by   discussions about Cubism, Kandinsky's non objective style, and Malevich's works in Suprematism. 










The pain and humiliation Georgia endured during the affair with Dorothy Norman was a major reason she lived in New Mexico and he lived in New York. Stieglitz had several heart attacks and she would come back and find Mrs. Norman in his hospital room. Georgia would be the one who was with him while he was convalescing after the hospitalizations. The film was shot entirely in New Mexico. Her home and studio in Abiquiu were used for actual interior shots and give the viewer the opportunity to see the minimalism in her life in New Mexico. Despite all the angst she endured during her years with Stieglitz, it was her desire to return to New York for Stieglitz to die in her arms.  

The two films complement each other. Which to watch first? Viewers who do not know much about the subject would probably enjoy the narrative with its intense drama. Watching the documentary first does not give the same insight into the manipulative and abusive personality of Stieglitz that is revealed in the narrative film. The documentary provides considerably more facts and information about the era.
  
The documentary film has several interviews. O’Keeffe’s 1980 interviews are used. Sue Davidson Lowe, whose mother owned the apartment that Georgia lived in, wrote a biography about her great uncle and is in the documentary. But the documentary also relies on a third person narrator  to provide much of the details and that tends to make it more like a lecture. In the narrative film an older O’Keeffe with first person voice over periodically appears. The film effortlessly moves back and forth through time, with costume, makeup and subtle changes in Joan Allen’s voice. A copy of the long buttoned single combination shirt and prairie skirt that O’Keeffe wore for the interviews is worn by Joan Allen in the flash forward portions of the film. 

The narrative film portrays Dorothy Norman as a sexually aggressive, airhead bimbo, who married into Sears and Roebuck money. She is in awe of Stieglitz and O'Keeffe and wants to be what today would be considered a groupie. Actually she came from a prominent family before she was married. She was active in many liberal causes, including The American Civil Liberties Union National Urban League, and the Group Theater. She wrote a weekly column for the New York Post, and edited the literary journal Twice a Year. She spoke German and French. She provided the liberal intellectual assets that Georgia couldn't. Stieglitz taught her photography and her photographs of the avant-garde are held by several museums. Many of the iconic photographs of Stieglitz were taken by Mrs. Norman. Stieglitz needed someone new as O'Keeffe was becoming famous and emerging from the shadow of his tutelage. After Stieglitz's death in 1946 she went on to write his biography as well as several other books.

Filming entirely in New Mexico might be problematic for some viewers who are familiar with Upstate New York or the paintings she did during her visits to Lake George not far from Vermont. The lawn on which she and Stieglitz play croquet is thin and anemic and not like the lush lawns of homes in the region. The pine trees are Pinyon and Ponderosa instead of Eastern White Pine. No, Alfred didn't go to New Mexico to convalesce.


                                                                                                                                                                                       

Top row center and right, and bottom row left, are Jeremy Irons who plays Allred Stieglitz in the film Georgia O'Keeffe. The other three images are Stieglitz.

Saturday, May 7, 2016

A look at the Metropolis: from Prostitutes, Lustmord, and Cabarets, to Economic Recovery in Weimar Germany and the New Objectivity

The recent exhibit, New Objectivity: Modern German Art in the Weimar Republic, 1919–1933,  at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art was a very comprehensive thematic exhibit but somewhat complicated. Retrospective exhibits of an artist, or exhibits about a particular style such as the numerous shows on French Impressionism, or exhibits about a genre are much easier to understand. The New Objectivity was not a genre, art style or group of artists with a manifesto . The turbulent years of the Weimar Republic and the different art styles don't fall into a neat package. New Objectivity is the translation of Neue Sachlichkeit, a 1925 exhibition in Mannheim, that broke away from pre-war Expressionism. To convey Germany's devastating aftermath of the War and the ensuing inter war years of sexual expression, developments in industry and shifting gender identities a new realism would be needed. "Objectivity" implies a lack of interpretation or insight. However sachlich the adjective can mean "matter of fact" or "impartial." Sachlichkeit as a noun and has the implication of "that's the way things are". In much of the art of the New Objectivity there is plenty of interpretation. Verism, a term to show all the gritty details in a painting of sculpture can be exaggerated for social typecasting, sarcasm and emotional expression. New Objectivity is more of a practical engagement with the ongoing political and cultural events.

Pre-War Prostitutes


Prostitutes were on the streets of Berlin in large numbers even before the war.  Kirchner moved to Berlin in 1911 and soon started painting his Street Scene series. Although they are in his expressionistic Die Brücke style with emotionally agitated zigzag angular brush strokes, there is realism in his representation of the prostitution in Berlin before the war. There was essentially no attempt by the police to restrict prostitution to designated areas of the city. Kirchner’s images reinforce the prevailing attitude that a well-dressed and behaved woman would be permitted on the fashionable streets. He also is one of the first artists to bring to Berlin the flâneur (stroller), essential to any literary work or painting of 19th century Paris.

After the war the number of prostitutes dramatically rose. The financial ruin of middle class families meant they could no longer afford their house servants who were frequently young unmarried women. It would be several years before there would be employment opportunities in the regrowth of industry. Ethnic Germans who before the war were living in the Eastern provinces of Prussia or Eastern Europe now found themselves in areas captured by Russia. Refugees, frequently widows with children, increased the population of Berlin. The unskilled unmarried woman suffered more than men during the hyperinflation from 1921 to 1924. Germany did not fund the war with taxes, borrowing or bonds. A victory and annexing territories rich in resources and industry was the plan to finance the War. The Mark devalued steadily during the war rom about 4 to 8 Marks to the Dollar. In November 1923 the exchange rate was 4,210,500,000,000 Marks to the Dollar.

Berlin became a destination for foreign sex tourists with convertible hard currency like Pounds Sterling or Dollars. Every specialty and age was available on the streets, in the brothels, private clubs, and the cabarets.

Currency revaluation plans were attempted, but it wasn't until 1925 that the economy was stabilizing. By 1925 about a third of the Germany's women were in the work force. Feminist culture studies blame the misogyny of Weimar culture to the New Woman taking jobs away from veterans.








Post-War Prostitutes

Post war New Objectivity depicted prostitution on the streets sarcastically and more realistically. Kirchner had both the women and the men fashionably dressed. He presented the prostitutes as integrated into street scenes on a par with the bourgeois flâneurs. But prostitutes don't act like the bourgeois strolling the sidewalks going to cafes or cabarets or looking at the fashions in the department store windows. They walk slower, often linger, make frequent eye contact, and nod to potential clients. It was illegal in Berlin for the prostitute to initiate a conversation. Fashion such as the color of their lace boots would be an indicator of their specialty.  Grosz's Before Sunrise, lacks the movement seen in Kirchner's street scenes, and their bodies are partially exposed. In Brüderstrasse a zaftig woman is leaning against the building. Dix's Three Prostitutes on the Street at fist glance looks like only the two standing on the right, with garish red blotchy faces are working. The one in the middle is in a typical pose hiking her skirt with her hand. The better dressed woman walking past them, with a blemish free white and her nose up in the air, looks like a bourgeois woman. The red gloves mark her as the third prostitute




The War Images


Otto Dix served in the forward trenches and kept a journal of what he experienced. In 1924, fifty of his etchings were published as Der Krieg The fright on the soldier in Wounded Soldier is probably because he knows he will be left lying in no man's land to die. Going "over the top" for an assault on the enemy's forward trench was suicidal. The new machine gun gave the advantage to the defensive positions.
It was not long after the war started that there was a stalemate as both sides dug a series of trenches from the sea to the Swiss border.



Well-dressed stretcher-bearers or ambulance drivers pay no attention to the victims of nerve gas or chlorine gas.
The German government censored images of poison gas victims during the war. In Great Britain The Daily Mirror
had a front page picture of two dead soldiers in a trench. The headline read, "DEVILRY, THY NAME IS GERMANY!": SOLDIERS TRAPPED BY A GAS CLOUD, LIE UNCONSCIOUS IN A TRENCH."



Death was a constant reality in the forward trenches – a sniper's bullet, artillery shell or a cloud of chlorine gas. This soldier must eat with the skeleton of death next to him.






The gas masks with the dark lenses surrounded by white make these troops look like living dead.











The returning troops are poorly clothed and look like walking dead. The administrative officer is well fed and has a clean  nicely fitting uniform.  In Stanley Kubrick’s anti-war film, Paths of Glory (1957) the French General goes into one the forward trenches to lend moral support before the assault. A shell explodes and he is annoyed that his uniform sleeve got dirty. He sops talking to the soldier as he becomes preoccupied wiping off the sleeve of his ornate dress uniform.







Dix's art dealer, Karl Nierendorf. would not include Soldier Raping a Nun in the original 1924 portfolio publication of the Der Kreig series. He felt it would be degrading to the surviving veterans tarnishing the image of the German hero. This event was never witnessed by Dix.

















Mud was an enemy to soldiers to both the Allied and Central powers fighting in the trenches. Front line trenches were often shallow and didn't have walking boards. The next several rows of trenches were deeper and often had duck boards. After rains the water and mud often rose above the boards. Feet that were wet for as little as a day started to developed blisters and swelling. A few days more there were open sores and fungal infections. Later stages were characterized by tissue necrosis that required amputation. Having someone else in the platoon responsible to check a soldiers foot daily became highly effective in controlling the condition. Washing and drying the foot was the prevention.

Picasso's famous painting Guernica is considered the most powerful work about the horrors of aerial warfare to helpless civilians. But Guernica is symbolic painting that has almost as many interpretations as viewers. Dix's expressionistic sketch doesn't require interpretation. The terror in the faces of the of the women and children in the foreground running from the Allied biplane is so intense that it is felt by the viewer and doesn't need interpretation. Adding to the tension is that the plane is low and large, almost touching the roofs on both sides of the street. With it's nose pointing down it looks like the plane had been in aerial combat and is now going to crash in the street. The dead people lying on the street make it clear that the plane deliberately strafed the street. The picture might have been more famous if it were a German plane committing the atrocity.




The environmental destruction of the battlefield has a haunting quality as he captured how the field looked from a falling flare. The craters would fill with rain and would slow an advance through no man's land giving the defensive machine gunners in the front trenches soldiers an even better advantage.




The dead sentry has a bare foot and  mangled limbs probably from an exploding artillery shell. Dix has vividly shown numerous ways a soldier could meet death at any moment.

Dix explained in an interview why he volunteered to go to the front trenches. "I had to experience how someone beside me suddenly falls over and is dead and the bullet has hit him squarely. I had to experience that quite directly. I wanted it. I’m therefore not a pacifist at all – or am I? Perhaps I was an inquisitive person. I had to see all that myself. I’m such a realist, you know, that I have to see everything with my own eyes in order to confirm that it’s like that. I have to experience all the ghastly, bottomless depths of life for myself…"









The soldier in the foreground is looking at the well dressed Belgium prostitutes and is disgusted at what he sees. He might be thinking that they are war profiteers but in fact they lived in terrible conditions and paid high prices for food and shelter. Venereal disease was so high among German soldiers, that the army had officially sanctioned brothels where military doctors inspected the women. The soldiers were issued ration coupons to the brothels. Dix often frequented the brothels.







Kirchner volunteered for military service in September 1914. In 1915, he  had a nervous breakdown and was drinking heavily and developed a dependence on morphine and barbiturates. He also had a hysterical paralysis with his hands and feet partially paralyzed. He returned to Berlin and painted Self Portrait as a Soldier. It is in his imagination that he has lost his right hand and no longer will be able to paint. Feminist criticism of this painting is that Kirchner is blaming  the nude model for not being able to paint and be creative. In this painting there is no emotional connection between him and the model, as there was in his previous works wit a model in the background. Kirchner stands detached and castrated without a hand in front of what he would need to make art – an easel and a model. Later Kirchner was living in Davos Switzerland and was convinced the Germans would invade. He committed suicide in 1938.


Lustmord


Lustmord is usually translated as "sex-murder." However, the German word lust is similar to the English words lust or pleasure. Lustmord art appeared even before the war ended. Henrich Maria Davringhausen’s , The Sex Killer, 1917, is strikingly similar to Manet’s Olympia 1917 with a cat on the bed but also a serial killer under the bed. What caused this graphic art in Germany has been intesely debated. The general thread in feminist  criticism since the 1970's has been that there were social anxieties about the roll of women that artists, intellectuals, and the middle class shared or Men’s fear of women was heightened by the feelings of vulnerability and impotence that soldiers had experienced during the war.

A simpler more direct explanation is that there was an unusual number of serial killers in Germany. There were frequent sensational headlines that had the population  constantly aware about serial killers. The artists were drawing what was happening rather than anti women sentiments.  During one week in February 1909, thirty Berlin women were stabbed by an unknown attacker. B.Z. am Mittag (Berlin newspaper at noon) put on the front page "Das Schrecken von Berlin" (the fright of Berlin). Newspaper sellers announced the headlines to sell papers and many of the serial killers had vivid nicknames.

Fritz Haarmann, who sexually assaulted and dismembered at least 42 boys and young men from 1918 until his arrest in 1924, was known as both the Butcher of Hanover because of his mutilation of the bodies and the Vampire of Hanover because he usually bit through the neck into the throat.
In August 1921, Carl Friedrich Grossmann was arrested in his apartment after neighbors heard a woman screaming. The police found a dead woman on the bed. Neighbors then told the police that many women had gone to his apartment for several years but they couldn’t recall more than a few who had left. Großmann sold meat on the black market and also had frankfurter stand.

Friedrich Schumann raped and killed women between 1911 and 1919,and was known as the “Massenmörder vom Falkenhagener”. His title has often been translated into English as the Terror of Falkenhagen Lake, however the German word Massenmörder means mass murderer. His infamy continued because  Schumann went to trial and was beheaded two years later in 1921

In 1924, Karl Denke was arrested after he attacked a man with an axe. Police searched his home and found flesh in jars of curing salts. Denke had methodically kept a ledger that had details of at lest 42 people he had killed and eaten. He hanged himself in jail before he acquired a nickname.

During most of 1929, Peter Kürten committed a series of rapes and murders and was known as the Düsseldorf Monster. After he drank the blood of a killed swan he was also known as the Vampire of Düsseldorf. Prior to his arrest it was not known if the Butcher and the Vampire of Düsseldorf were the same person


The executioner was also part of the public spectacle. Carl Gröpler wore a tailcoat, top hat, and white gloves. His identity was not secret. Theodor Lessing, the German Jewish philosopher, nicknamed him the "Red Judge." Gröpler used an axe to behead the condememed. In some cities he used a guillotine.

During the early years of the Republic, there were several classic German Expressionism horror films. In F. W. Murnau’s Nosferatu (1922). Orlok a vampire terrorizes the city of Wisborg. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920) directed by Robert Wiene, features an insane hypnotist who uses a somnambulist to commit murders. In The Head of Janus (1920) directed by F. W. Murnau, a Dr. Warren played by Conrad Veidt is transformed into the madman Mr. O'Connor through a bust of Janus and then terrorizes the city.

Georg Wilhelm Pabst directed Pandora's Box (1929). The American actress Louise Brooks who popularized the flapper look with the bobbed hairstyle and short skirt, played Lulu a woman who had committed two murders and fled to London. She is in a desperate financial situation and becomes a street prostitute. Out of the London fog lurks Jack. A sign (in German) on a wall warns London women about a man who is killing women. She entices Jack to be her first customer. He says he has no money but she says she likes him and invites him inside, perhaps because It is Christmas eve. They embrace on the stairs and Jack pulls a knife out of his pocket. After the camera has lingered on the knife, he decides to drop it. When they embrace inside her room, he sees another knife on the table. There are reaction shots of his demonic expressions and cuts back to the knife. He finally can’t control his urge and kills her.

In 1931 Fritz Lang’s M, about a serial killer of children in Berlin was released. There were no vampires, hypnotisms or transformations, but there was Peter Lorre in his first role, playing the creepy looking serial killer Franz Becker. Alfred Hitchcock, who had worked in Germany in 1924 and 1925, continued to make films about serial killers for almost half a century. In The Lodger (1927), “The Avenger” kills blonde women on Tuesday nights. In Shadow of a Doubt (1943), Charlotte "Charlie" Newton suspects her Uncle Charles "Charlie" Oakley of being the "Merry Widow Murderer". With the similarity in names is Hitchcock saying there is the potential for murder inside each of us? In Psycho (1960) Norman Bates had poisoned his Mother and Stepfather. Ten years later he stabbed Marion Crane in the shower. In Frenzy (1972), "The Necktie Murderer” is raping women and then strangling them.

The War Wounded


Otto Dix made several satirical paintings and sketches of wounded veterans. The Match Seller, reveals a blind veteran missing both legs. The three well dressed people from higher classes, who probably did not serve in the trenches or as nurses in battlefield hospitals, are hurrying away from him. Only their lower extremities are seen. The little daschund is lifting his leg and urinating on the veteran's stump.







There are two amputee veterans in Pragerstrasse, 1920. In the shop window are artificial limbs, trusses, and a corset. An well off gentleman wearing  a gold cuff link is dropping  a worthless postage stamp into the man's hand. Under the wheels of the board that supports the other veteran  is a leaflet that says, "Juden raus!" (Jews out!). Veteran organizations were usually anti-Semitic and a ready made audience for ultra-nationalist propaganda.










Large gaping facial wounds were often seen in surviving veterans. World War I ordinance did not have the explosive power to create small high velocity fragments of the casing. The larger slower moving fragments caused large soft tissue wounds. Two Victims of Capitalism shows a prostitute with a syphilitic lesion on her face that looks like a bullet hole and a veteran with a battlefield wound that is shaped like a vagina. The original title was Whore With War Cripple, but was renamed when it was reprinted in the communist journal Die Pleite.







The caustic irony in Otto Dix's War Cripples is that the three men who have lost their legs
are now parading past a shoe maker's shop with the sign "Schuhmacherei" and the boot in the window.



In Dix's The Salon, aging women are surviving the economic crisis by resorting to prostitution. The under weight women on the right is revealing her long pendulous breasts through the shear flimsy gown. Thy patiently sit waiting to make some money.


The Cabarets

The left panel of Metropolis  shows a crippled war veteran in a poor section of Berlin being greeted by a line of prostitutes. A man is lying or dead in the street. In the center panel is the prosperity of the city inside a jazz club or cabaret. On the right are the flashy prostitutes in an affluent part of the city.

In Tingel-Tangel the patrons seem to be oblivious to the partially naked performers. The man in an army uniform is not watching the show. the two well to do men, one in a Fedora, the other with a monocle also are not interested. The partially naked prostitute at the table in Ziegler's Couple at a Table, doesn't seem to be successful at stimulating the man. Probably all she will get from him is the drink and she will move on to another table.



To Beauty is a self portrait of Otto Dix. There really is no beauty in this brothel. Only Dix and the drummer seem to have any emotion. Dix with a threatening look and the black man with an absurd smile that reinforces a racial stereotype.  The handkerchief in his breast pocket is an American flag. 1922 is a little early for Black musicians to be performing in Berlin. At this time most black musicians were in Paris. The torso of the woman is supported by a metal pole and is mannequin for wigs.



Max Beckmann revealed himself through a series of self portraits over his career. Self- portrait with Champagne glass was done a few months after he was in Berlin during the bloody street battles of the March Rebellion in 1919. His glass of champagne is upright but the wall is canted. Alcohol could provide comfort in a violent distorted city.

He was awarded a very prestigious university position in Frankfort in 1927, and felt that artists were part of a social elite and ambassadors of the state. . The tuxedo was his uniform. There is very little in the painting to detract from the black and white of his uniform, while  he  portrays himself as self assured and arrogant.





Anita Berber frequently danced in cabarets totally nude. Her drug addiction and bisexuality were no secret. Besides alcohol, cocaine and opiates she was partial to chloroform mixed with ether. She frequently would be in a hotel lobby nude but partially covered with a fur coat. There is no anti male criticism of Grosz portrayal of the well to do cabaret patron as a pig. The nude prostitute at his cabaret table has been the target of how male artists portray women.


Fetishes for Every Fancy


There is a definite realism in Rudolf Schlicter art about sado masochism because he also was an avid practitioner. In 1927, he met Elfriede Elisabeth Koehler, he called Speedy, a prostitute from Geneva who had a passion for bondage.. Later he felt he needed to be punished for his transgressions and re joined the Catholic Church and started moving in conservative circles. He has been quoted as saying, "There is no more unfortunate creature under the sun than a fetishist who yearns for a woman’s shoe and has to settle for the whole woman.”

Meeting of Fetishists and Maniacal Flagellants is a realistic depiction of a group scene that has not changed in clubs today – nude submissives and clothed dominants and voyeurs.










The gay and lesbian magazines ran ads for the clubs and also personal ads. In 1923 an personal ad read, A young married couple seeks social connection. Wouldn't it be nice if we were similarly sympathetic?" Police were known to write letters to the magazines. Certain level of vagueness was required  to avoid a fine. A man named Bock responded to an ad saying, "Wouldn't it be lovely if we could exchange our wives and enjoy communal love? We are 26 and 28 years old . My wife is skinny and red-blond. I am dark and of middle height." Block was arrested and fined  for obscenity.























Schlicther's own personal experience gave his work more realism than other artists' work about alternative sexual activities.


Androgyny
Otto dix has exagerated the androgynous look of Sylvia von Harden,  a poet and writer of short stories who frequented the Romanisches Café in Berlin and sat at her corner table. The café regulars were the who's who of the Belin avante garde, including Oto Dix, Bertolt Brecht, George Grosz, Alfred Döblin, Joachim Ringelnatz, Erich Maria Remarque, and Billy Wilder. Aspiring writers would go the Romanisches Café in hopes of launching their careers. Those already established were at tables séparées. At the beginning of the 1972 musical film Cabaret, about 20 seconds after Joel Grey starts to sing "Willkommen", there is a brief recreation of this painting. Von Harden loved this caricature of herself. Many of the industrialists hated the distortions in their portraits by Dix. Her female figure is flattened by the dress. The fingers are grossly elongated and her left hand covers her breasts and the left goes across her pelvis. Her hair was in the new bob style or as it is called in German, Bubikopf. Dix told von Harden "I must paint you! I simply must! ... You are representative of an entire epoch!' The monocle was Dix's idea.



The more traditional couple in the background are gossiping about the absurdity of Fräulein Mia a man wearing high heeled shoes or a woman in a man's jacket and tie. She forgets she has her hair almost as short in the now accepted Bubikopf.




Many of the works of Anton Räderscheidt depict a stiff couple where the woman resembles his wife the painter Martha Hegemann. There is the implication that he has painted himself as a woman, although the self portrait maybe him in front of a painting of a woman.

 Marlene Dietrich's androgynous costumes and dress were known world wide but it happened after she left Germany. Josef von Sternberg, the Austrian American film director was invited to make the first feature-length full-talkie in Germany, The Blue Angel (1930), a co production of Paramount and UFA. English and German versions were made simultaneously. Dietrich played Lola Lola, a cabaret performer in a top hat but with her legs exposed. Von Sternberg bought her to Hollywood, where they made six more films together. In her first American film Morocco (1930), Sternberg insisted that she wear a black tuxedo. Her insatiable sexual appetite for both women and men started in Germany, but received its notoriety in America.


Gender Issues


Gay magazines started being published before the turn of the century and and increased after the war. Magnus Hirschfeld a Jewish German physician became the world’s most renowned sexologist. A journalist Maximilian Harden  published an article in 1907,  that General Kuno von Moltke was having a homosexual relationship with Prince Philip von Eulenburg, Kaiser Wilhelm’s best friend. Molke filed criminal liabilty against Harden, who was found not guilty. A civil suit followed. The homosexual cicle around the Kaiser and in the military was exposed. From 1906 to 1907, six military officers committed suicide. Hirschfeld, a homosexual, testified that homosexuality was part of a normal spectrum of of human sexuality. The judge, outraged because “homosexuals have the morals of  dogs” reversed the jury verdict. Nationalist political groups  and newspapers (völkisch) relentleslly villified him as a Jew and homosexual. Posters appeared that read, “Dr. Hirschfeld A Public Danger: The Jews are Our Undoing!”

Under the liberal Weimar Reublic he opened in 1919 the Institute of Sexual Research in Berlin.


In last year’s film The Danish Girl, Lili goes to Weimar Germany for her sex reassignment surgery. Actually she had four surgical procedures. The first was done in Berlin under Hirschfeld’s supervision was removal of the testicles. The other three were performed in Dresden by Kurt Warnekros, a gynecologist. The procedures included an ovary implanted into the abdominal wall, the removal of her external genitalia, and then a uterine transplant with vaginal construction. She died after the fourth procedure. To perform the transplant in an era without tissue typing, antibiotics, and immunosuppressive drugs to prevent transplant rejection was the result of a surgeon’s overextended ego and criminal.

Krall was a well known homosexual who travelled in openly gay circles. In this portrait Dix has him turned in a pose more typical of female models. Dix has exaggerated his appearance by painting him as if he were squeezed into a tight corset painting his head red as if the blood were stagnating in the skin. Possibly he is wearing lipstick and makeup. His name Krall is similar to the word "Kralle" which means claw or talon. Dix has distorted the fingers of the left hand to be like claws as they grasp his jacket. The painting is culturally important because it is from an era when homosexuals were becoming more visible and important.

The Economic Recovery


How Germany went from a defeated country in 1919 with the burden of massive reparations payments, triple digit inflation during  the immediate post war years followed by the hyper inflation from 1921 to 1924, an economic crisis in 1931 during the world wide Great Depression, to a rearmed country that was able to wage war against France, England, the Soviet Union, and the United States  was beyond most of the world's comprehension. The Treaty Versailles imposed harsh reparations on Germany to pay for the cost of civilian damage in Europe. The total cost was set at 132 billion gold Marks (US$ 33 billion).
In 1923 Germany defaulted on its quota to deliver steel and iron. Belgium and France then occupied the Ruhr valley. Future Vice President of the United States, Charles G. Dawes reorganized the reparations and the United States loaned Germany $800 million. When the Mark stabilized foreign investment came into Germany. In 1929 Owen Young, ex president of RCA created a plan to end the reparations. The plan would be financed with loans from U.S. Investment banks and coordinated by J.P Morgan. These plans closely linked the German economy to that of the United States and subsequently Germany was directly affected by the Depression of the 1930’s. During a depression prices drop and those with money can buy more goods and services. Foreign tourists with money liked what they could now get at bargain prices in the cabarets and clubs of Berlin

The Profiteer, 1920-1921was made during the low triple digit inflation. The safe on the right contains no money. Only a small businessman would need money. He only needs a telephone in his office. He could borrow money to buy materials or other companies and then pay back the loan when the money was worthless. This cycle initially helped the German economy. The skyscrapers without any ornamentation on the facades did not exist at this time. Fritz Lang’s vision of stripped down facades in the film Metropolis was filmed in 1926. The Empire State Building with minimal ornamentation on the lower floors was started in 1930
Most of the battlefields on  the western front were in Belgium and France. Some of the Eastern Front battles were in East Prussia, which is now Poland. German industrial sites were intact after the war. An intact industrial infrastructure allowed Germany to experience a more rapid economic expansion.






Karl Völker also worked as an architect. His paintings of buildings have very strong diagonal lines and receding perspectives to emphasize the architectural structures.







Concrete, also known as Factory by a Railroad Track has the look of tracks  descending into the factory. The diagonal of the top of the brown wall on the right causes this illusion. In realty trains can only navigate very low grades. The slow speed required to go into the factory to be loaded or unloaded  would necessitate there be no grade.





Grossberg's industrial images are using "precisionisn," considered an American style developed after WWI. The style suited Hitler well to showcase his modern and rapid tecnologocal growth. The precisionist style was in keeping with the goals of national socialism.









This photo essay starts before the Weimar era with Krichner's expressionism of pre war Berlin street Scenes. It ends a year after Hitler becomes Chancellor with these industrial Precisionist  paintings.
Most of the pevious works were labeled Entartete Kunst or  Degenerate Art and were confiscated from public museums in German. Hitler picked what he liked about America before the Second World War including most Hollywood films but not Jazz, Swing Dancing, Benny Goodman, or Olympic Medalist Jesse Owens.